
Everyone knows that I am a LOST nut. I love this show. It is a complex puzzle of emotions, character flaws, redemption, deceit, love, love lost, love found, confusion, mystery and science. A place where the boundaries of the known and unknown begin to blur.
I have talked to many since the season preiemere of LOST season 5 and many are so LOST that I fear they may lose interest. Before you do, I have decided to take on the task of attempting to explain a few items that may be helpful to the reader. Before I get started I will warn you that the following isn't like any of my former posts. This post is serious in its build, there will be some references to math but not without some sarcastic quips, but stay with me, some of it may seem a bit much to swallow, but I wanted to clear up a few things for those who love this show like myself, but may still find themselves confused.
Here we go (hang on...its a bumpy ride):
The first item you must understand is Time. Time is the fourth dimension of which we (as mere humans) don't seem to have ability to control. We tell stories and make movies about bending time, shifting it, because it is the unknown. The perceived ability to do such would seemingly place us among the gods.
Time is a huge part of the show.
Time is relative. (Here comes the math and confusing part...stay with me) Stephen Hawking's 'A Brief History of Time' (a book referenced in the show several times in passing) is an attempt for a basic understanding of string theory, and or time travel. It gets really confusing but in a nutshell it says space (all three dimensional space, not just outerspace) and time are relative to each other. When people say something is 'relative' to something else, usually it means that there is a constant and a variable.
A simple example is a basic algebraic equation:
2 + x = ?
The constant is 2 the variable is x. Whatever you do to the variable will directly affect the outcome. In order for the equation to work, one must accept that no matter what happens to the variable, the constant cannot be changed (see, and you thought you would never use your high school algebra).
Even one seemingly simple alteration in the constant will frustrate the equation. (Remember this....its important a few paragraphs down.)
An item or persons existence in time is relative (or dependent) upon its existence in three dimensional space. There are rules to the manipulation of time. Daniel Faraday explains to Sawyer that time is like a string, you can move forward or backward on the string, but you cannot create a new string. This is why he stops Sawyer from talking to Desmond because "If it doesn't happen, it CAN'T happen".
I know you are getting confused now...stay with me for a min more...
Let me give you an analogy of this theory of "rules of time". Imagine a wool scarf, plaid design, grey in color. If you pull really hard on the fabric in opposite directions, you can see the individual strings. If you were to take just one string and pull on it, it would simply snap, but woven together they become very strong, they hold heat, they last for years on end without fraying and falling apart. However, if I were to take a knife and cut even one string (e.g. Sawyer meeting Desmond before it actually happens) The fabric is broken, weakened and will fall apart quickly as its ability to hold to itself becomes impossible. Keeping this fabric woven is essential to the longevity of the scarf. The same is true about time.
As I said before, even one seemingly simple alteration in the constant will frustrate the equation.
Just as the analogy of the scarf, if the fabric (or equation) of time is compromised, so are both the future and past. I believe this is why Locke and Ben are so adamant that Jack and the other survivors don't leave, they know how it will affect the string of future events. Why they don't just come out and tell us that, I don't know, but that adds to the mystery. Locke keeps telling Jack what he is 'supposed' to do and that makes Jack mad. Jack, remember, is a man of science and Locke is a man of faith. Jack won't believe in miracles, I think he soon will, just like in the earlier seasons, Locke was an unbeliever of miracles too.
So....how does all this talk about time and space relate to the show? Simple, the constant in this show is the island, therefore all other events are relative to the Island and its place in space and time. Instead of getting confused about a specific year of any event that happens off the island, (i.e. flash forwards, or flash backs) lets call those events 'Alternate Time' or 'AT'. Any events that happen on the island (real time) we will call 'Current Time' or 'CT'.
Everybody with me so far?
Everything, since the very first episode of the first season, that has happened on the island has happened in CT. Every flashback we have seen has been in AT. Whether those events happen in the past or future, they are AT time to the constant. Since we don't know the order of the events in AT, they can become confusing. As the show moves along, we are revealed more and more about AT events of our characters, usually in the past, which tells us more and more about their character and why they make the decisions they do.
Everyone still with me?
Everything that happens on the Island is CT.....since the very first episode of the first season, that has been consistant in the writers storytelling. Which brings us to the season 5 opener. I think many have forgotten that the events we are seeing are happening in separate dimensions of time. (Don't get confused yet) Let me make this easy to understand.
First lets define who is on the Island:
Locke
Juliet
Charlotte
Sawyer
Daniel
Miles
If the show is constant to the storytelling, these characters are in CT. This is VERY important to remember.
Lets now define who is off the island:
Ben
Sayid
Kate
Hurley
Sun
Jack
Desmond....(more on him later)
Again, if the show is constant to the storytelling of seasons past, these characters are in AT. This, also is very important to remember. Lets reacap: Aaron is 3 years older, Jack and Kate are 3 years down the road of their rocky relationship, Sun's baby is about 2 1/2, Jin has been assumed dead for 3 years, Sayid found Nadia, married and she was murdered, Ben has seemingly leaped over all that time and has ended up about the same time as the rest (remember he didn't know the year when he made the leap after turning the wheel), Hurley has been in a mental institution for years and Desmond found Penny.....more on Desmond later.
Watching season 5 gives the illusion that all the events are happening in CT when in fact (just like all the other seasons) you are seeing events in AT and CT. The lines are less blurred and less defined as in past, but I think this is done for a reason.
OK....still with me?
Look at the picture I posted at the top (I found this online and think it is perfect to the explanation). Each group is divided from each other, literally, in three dimensional space and time. You will notice that Desmond is almost right in the middle, somewhat covered by both.....I don't think this is an accident.
Desmond is unique (as Dr. Faraday suggests) to the space time continuum. For some reason, he bridges the gap, or can travel backward and forward on the string of time mentally. Space and time seem to be relative to Desmond to some degree which is why he suddenly has a 'new memory' three years into the future (or AT) about meeting Faraday outside the hatch (CT). Desmond is somehow the link between them all which is why the old lady tells him (in season 4) that the most important thing he will ever do in his life is push the button in the hatch for three years. One can only guess what pushing the button actually did.
There is one more piece that is confusing. If the events on the Island are CT, why is Richard Alpert and the rest of the "Others" unaffected by the shifts in CT to the survivors characters.....I don't know. I am sure the writers and producers do.
So.....to wrap this all up, lets ask a few questions:
- If the Oceanic 6 (and Ben and Locke) actually make it back to the island, what time will it be?
- If they find a way back to the island, will they have actually ever left?
- If they make it back and it is CT, will they remember the events in their AT future? Will that play into their relationships?
- Is Jin really dead or is he floating out in the ocean? If he is floating somewhere....what time is it? Where would he be in three dimensional space?
- If they make it back to the island, and their place in time and space is CT is Sun still expecting?
- Locke is seen alive in CT and dead in AT. If they correct the time shift will he still need to die in AT to keep the string in CT?
So many questions, it can send your brain humming.
I don't know of any other show that can do that. The writing, the stories, the unknown, the producers truly have outdone themselves. Now, knowing this, maybe it will help you understand what is happening in the show a little better.
Here are some additional thoughts not really relative to the space time discussion:
Charles Widmore = Dharma initiative. Tried to take the island by force to produce some sort of experiments that he could use for his purposes. We don't really know if they were good purposes or not.
Ben Linus = Others. People who inhabit the island. They have lost the ability to reproduce and therefore recruit people to come to the island but never let them leave. Very protective of the island and willing to give all they have to protect it.
Other than that, I know about as much as everyone else.
Catey keeps telling me to "just sit back, enjoy the show, don't think so hard about it."...maybe she is right....................nah....